$ buildwith diff polar paddle

Polar vs Paddle

Both are in Payments, where we rank Polar #2 and Paddle #4. Everything below comes from each tool's own pricing and docs pages, with the date we last checked them. How we rank.

pick Polar if you're an indie dev selling software and want merchant-of-record handling.

pick Paddle if you're scaling SaaS and want an established merchant of record.

Polar

#2 · Usage-based

Polar is a billing platform and merchant of record for software and AI companies. It meters usage, runs subscriptions, and handles VAT, GST, and sales tax. The docs say the codebase is Apache 2.0.

for Developers selling digital products, subscriptions, or usage such as tokens and API calls. Organizations created on or after May 27, 2026 start on Starter.

use this if you're an indie dev selling software and want merchant-of-record handling.

pricing

  • Starter Free

    5% + 50¢ per transaction. This is the rate for organizations created on or after May 27, 2026.

  • Pro $20/month

    3.8% + 40¢ per transaction, with prioritized support. The docs put the breakeven versus Starter at about $1,379 a month in sales.

  • Growth $100/month

    3.6% + 35¢ per transaction.

  • Scale $400/month

    3.4% + 30¢ per transaction, plus Slack support and single sign-on. International cards add 1.5%. Disputes are $15 regardless of outcome.

features

  • ›Usage meters and credits that draw down and top up
  • ›Subscriptions with trials, upgrades, and proration
  • ›Hosted checkout, embedded checkout, and a Checkout API
  • ›Merchant of record: tax, fraud, refunds, and chargebacks
  • ›License keys, file downloads up to 10 GB, GitHub access, and Discord roles
  • ›A Startup Program on the homepage that offers the Scale rate free for 12 months to early-stage AI startups

strengths

  • ›You can start at $0, and Polar is the merchant of record.
  • ›The fee steps down as you add a monthly plan, and the breakeven sales levels are published.
  • ›Usage-based billing and credits are part of the product.

limits

  • ›Starter's 5% + 50¢ is higher than Stripe's domestic card rate because tax handling is included.
  • ›Transaction fees are not returned on refunds.
  • ›Upgrading off the Early Member rate (4% + 40¢, for organizations created before May 27, 2026) retires it. A later downgrade lands on Starter at 5% + 50¢.

why #2

Ranked #2 in payments because Polar is the merchant of record aimed at indie and AI products, with a free start and a fee that drops on a paid plan. Stripe ranks first when you want to be the merchant at the card rate. Lemon Squeezy is the similar 5% + 50¢ merchant of record for digital goods. Paddle is the established SaaS merchant of record at the same headline fee.

sources

open polar.sh ↗

Paddle

#4 · Usage-based

Paddle is a merchant of record for digital product businesses. It manages payments, tax, compliance, and billing. The homepage says it covers 300+ markets. ProfitWell Metrics and Retain are separate products for subscription metrics and failed-payment recovery.

for SaaS and mobile-app companies selling globally. Custom pricing is for high-volume businesses and for products priced under $10.

use this if you're scaling SaaS and want an established merchant of record.

pricing

  • Pay as you go 5% + 50¢

    Per checkout transaction. No monthly fee, no migration fee, and the FAQ says there is no lock-in period. Payments, tax compliance, fraud protection, and buyer support are included.

  • Under $10 products Custom

    The pricing page says products under $10 need a bespoke rate. That rate is not published.

  • Custom Contact sales

    For high-volume or more complex needs, including a dedicated customer-success contact.

features

  • ›A branded checkout you can embed
  • ›Subscriptions and recurring billing
  • ›Sales tax and VAT compliance
  • ›Fraud protection, chargebacks, and buyer support
  • ›Invoicing and reporting
  • ›Migration help on custom plans

strengths

  • ›The published plan has no monthly fee.
  • ›Buyer support for payment, subscription, and cancellation questions is included in the fee.
  • ›Tax and compliance are the reason for the merchant-of-record model.

limits

  • ›Products priced under $10 are not on the published 5% + 50¢ rate.
  • ›ProfitWell Metrics and Retain prices are not on the pricing page.
  • ›The page does not publish a separate rate for subscriptions versus one-time checkout.

why #4

Ranked #4 in payments because Paddle is the established SaaS merchant of record, which matters more as volume grows. Stripe, Polar, and Lemon Squeezy rank above it for a first sale with a fully public self-serve price. Paddle is the pick when you want the same 5% + 50¢ model and a sales-assisted plan for scale.

sources

open www.paddle.com ↗
sponsor this spot →